I am just starting out, but am trying to find out what grits I need and which stones I can mix. I have some uncut Amethyst, Uncut Emerals, Uncut Citrine, and about 2 lbs of Ruby Sapphire. I have been looking at grits as well as trying to find selelrs of grits. Can I mix any of these in the Rough Stage? Do I need Diamond Powder or ?Borine? Do I need to get some pellets still? I have a dual Tumbler.
Ruby and sapphire are both corundum, which is 9 on the Mohs scale of hardness... and that is hard! Few people tumble corundum. I'd suggest you start with quartz first, you'll see better results in much less time. Plenty of suggestions on grit to use and steps to follow can be found on this website if you just look around.
As someone who has tumbled more gemstone than agate to date, I'd also say start with something a little easier than especially the ruby/sapphire, <grin>. Wouldn't want you to get discouraged before you're well and truly hooked...
Of what I've done so far, the best results I've gotten have been citrine and topaz, and I've seen some great results others have had with garnet as well. The emeralds I've done have also come out pretty well, but being opaque and buried in matrix like they are they're not quite as good a result as the topaz and citrine have been. The amethyst I've gotten to date has been full of fractures and I haven't gotten much to brag about from those - maybe ten fairly nice stones out of 80-odd.
My ruby/sapphire tumbling results are just a few threads down on this page - and they've been tumbling off and on for nine months or so. The kind of ruby and sapphire that you get in these 'mine-run' mixes are not facet grade, they are completely opaque and at best are the variety that may star if cabbed rather than turn up clear like a stone you'd facet. Tumbled rather than cabbed, what I'm seeing with mine is that at some angles (especially when wet) you get a bit of 'depth' to the stone, and a bit of shimmer from [what I assume are] the layers of alumina - sort of like what you get from Labradorite or Moonstone, but not as flashy or colorful as Labradorite. I'll do my best one of these days to capture on camera what my eye can see.
The only stones you'd need anything diamond for would be the corundum (ruby/sapphire), and then only for the later stages - the emeralds, citrine and amethyst can be done just fine with regular grits and polishes, and the regular SC coarse and medium grits do a pretty good job for the early stages on the corundum as well. I've got a split experiment running right now, with some of the corundum in a tumbler with diamond paste (powder would have been fine too, just that you usually get more diamond per ml/gm in the paste than in a powder), and some in just regular polish or pre-polish. I am seeing some shine on the flatter areas with the ones that are in regular polish after a month of being in there (compared to a day or two for most other stones in a Lot-O at the polish stage), but it's nothing spectacular and I expect that I'd have to leave them in that polish for another six to nine months before they looked anything like polished stones on every side.
The ones in the diamond run are faring a bit better, have shown quite a bit of improvement in the week or so they've been running. I'll take some more pics in a couple of days. They're in a very small (1.1lb) vibe tumbler, btw - I wouldn't myself have wanted to try this with diamond in a 3lb rotary or 4+lb vibe, because it would get *very* expensive. I don't have any idea what diamond's breakdown rate is as compared to SC (for grit-renewal purposes), but even the initial amount needed would be fairly pricey. I want to say that I paid around $60 incl tax/ship for three 5-ml syringes (one 4k, one 14k, and one 50k mesh), and I'd think it would take most of one syringe to charge a 3lb or up tumbler just one time.
I probably wouldn't have taken on the corundum (or would have given up on it long before now) if I hadn't had other tumblers working on things that give better and faster results. Or if I hadn't had a Chicago Electric whose days I already knew were numbered without upgrading the motor, fan and pulley (I did change out the belt, pretty much a must with any CE as the ones they come with don't last) to put them in. It lasted long enough to get the corundum through coarse and medium, and having them there didn't hinder my progress on anything else, so it wasn't a particular hardship or trying-of-patience to have those taking up a barrel on that particular tumbler for that long. But if you're planning on doing them in one dual rotary, I'd definitely recommend starting with something that will show results a lot faster than corundum will.
great info, thank you. I also have the problem of obtaining highly polished rubies-sapphires; since the time you posted your thread, have you achieve better-faster results using different methods-abrasives?
mr.mohs: got busted for jay walking in Vegas... ...so I knew wouldn't have any luck gambling...mostly™
Aug 26, 2015 17:57:33 GMT -5
Fossilman: I was with a buddy that didn't have a brain! He stole a "Hookers" purse!! Told him not too,wouldn't be anything in it...Hey guess what,there wasn't anything in it!!! Glad I was underage! He wasn't!! They kind of rough him up a bit ......
Aug 27, 2015 9:11:28 GMT -5
Fossilman: The cops told me I should lose the bum,I guess he had a pretty good wrap sheet going in Cali and Montana...Went our different ways in Salt Lake City,Utah...
Aug 27, 2015 9:12:53 GMT -5
mr.mohs: your buddy took the line from the j.geils song to literally--- first I look at the purse
Aug 27, 2015 9:45:14 GMT -5
gemsgalore: I need some advice for tumbling my first opal. It's 2"w x 1-1/2"h, circumference is 4-1/2". I only have ceramic filler but no grinding grit on hand. Can I tumble without the grit?
Aug 27, 2015 10:22:46 GMT -5
jakesrocks: gemsgalore, please post your question here. http://andy321.proboards.com/board/22/totally-rock-tumbling
Aug 27, 2015 10:50:32 GMT -5
Fossilman: Ed-exactly!!! He seen the purse,told he was going to take it..I called him a moron and he proved to me,that I was right..I was 15,he was 23...
Aug 27, 2015 11:50:07 GMT -5
mr.mohs: gemsgalore-- I got better idea of what to do with that chunk of opal. Rather than put it in a barrel------- hand polish it with 37,000gr emery paper and save it as a specimen...mostly
Aug 27, 2015 17:15:54 GMT -5
dhotrocknut: Mike at least ya have an interesting tale to tell out of that mess.lol
Aug 28, 2015 18:24:51 GMT -5
dhotrocknut: FYI I'm no longer in Nevada and am going to get dinner and desert. I'll have to let you all know if it was worth the trip.
Aug 28, 2015 18:28:07 GMT -5
mr.mohs: get some sherbet ice cream for desert, diane.... that will cool you down... mostly
Aug 28, 2015 18:46:33 GMT -5
mikeyrocks: Hey ms D you on your way to S Cal? Safe travels
Aug 28, 2015 19:31:31 GMT -5
parfive: September Rock & Gem, coupla familiars on p29.
Aug 28, 2015 19:34:38 GMT -5
quartz: 1 1/2 hrs. steady rain this A.M., first since mid May. Thanks to all for doing your rain dances.
Aug 29, 2015 7:25:47 GMT -5
Fossilman: Yes Diana,there is more to that story too..LOL We received some good rain lastnite too,more coming this week...Los of thunder,liking that!
Aug 29, 2015 9:28:58 GMT -5
mr.mohs: certain corridor of Phoenix had a violent thunderstorm last night-- I was in the eye of the storm--- the rocks are o.k. mostly
Sept 1, 2015 8:53:09 GMT -5
rockpickerforever: Ed, I heard about that on the news this morning. It's a good thing your rocks are hard, lol. How did you fare?
Sept 1, 2015 11:00:01 GMT -5